RTFM and Stop Wasting Everybody’s Time
Making Linux usable by the “general public” was eschewed by the Linux community for years. Like teenage girls and fashion trends, hardcore Linux fans wanted to maintain the purity and, yes, the unrelenting geekiness, of their beloved operating system. Similarly, I cringe when I hear the melody Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony defiled by elementary school brass bands. Those not versed in the black arts of kernel programming were chastised when seeking Linux help on the internet. Ubuntu changed everything not by inventing new technology, but by introducing a new attitude. When I first tried Hoary Hedgehog in high school (2005), I had been seriously studying software development for three years, but had only spent a few hours using Linux. Trying to learn a new technology from such an insular community (at the time) was daunting. Back then, there were a few things that just weren’t feasible on Linux: using an ATI graphics card or an Intel wireless card, watching Flash videos, and using the “Sleep” function on your laptop. You couldn’t find drivers for your printer, but you could skin your menu bars to look like OS X. Like a popular xkcd comic points out, you could accommodate massively parallel computing (indeed, I built a CFD compute cluster using Fedora in 2007), but full-screen Flash video was unattainable. I once asked a question about my xorg.conf file when trying to set up multiple monitors in Dapper Drake (2006). The response from an expert was, in essence, RTFM and stop wasting everybody’s time. No wonder nobody used Linux. Following instructions from Linux geeks feels like trying to read Charles Dickens while having a stroke, and asking for help was even more painful. Sorry, I haven’t read Chapter 46: Mastering the Dark Arts of X Configuration.
If at first you do not succeed, Shamelessly Increment the Version Number
Ubuntu religiously releases a new version every six months. For years, following each release, a Slashdot pundit would herald in a new era of Linux in which the layperson could use Linux without help from an expert. That it Just Works™. Yet in trying each release, I continued to feel as if I were either too simple-minded to be a professional computer scientist, or that these people were using some magical computers that had been baptized by the Linux gods. Admittedly, each successive release was better, and compared to the pre-Ubuntu Linux dark ages of yore, the newest Ubuntu release was always cause for celebration. You mean I don’t have to re-compile my kernel in order for me to use a webcam? Sweet! Inevitably, however, there would be a show-stopper. Somehow from the 12,783 bugs that were fixed for this release, I still cannot scale my resolution past 640×480. I cannot use my laptop for school if my wireless network card card isn’t supported by your puritanical non-proprietary driver database. It isn’t my fault that my laptop was cursed with a Broadcom chipset at manufacture. However, more and more of these problems faded away with each release. Not only did configuration become easier, more stuff began to work out of the box. Now — finally — almost everything does.
Version 1.0
Ubuntu is finally out of beta, and Version 1.0 is finally here. The Ubuntu folks are calling it 11.10, but we all know what it really is: the first version that is competitive with Windows and OSX. Version 1.0. I know this because I replaced Windows 7 on my laptop with Ubuntu 11.10 and, since everything works, I don’t have to revert back to Windows like I have so many times before. Maybe next time, though, Canonical will bless its harbinger of mass-appeal with a an animal adjective that isn’t flagged by my browser’s spellcheck, and that the average person can pronounce. Luckily, the name “Oneiric Ocelot” will be replaced six months hence.
I will be disappointed if some neckbeard doesn’t come in here and rant and rave about how his platform is infested with idiots now.
-
I was just considering doing that! Get outta my head and off my operating system!
2:30 pm | March 12, 2012 -
This attitude. Sure, there are arrogant and conservative personalities in the FLOSS community. But the majority passionate volunteers.
By kicking down at “some neckbeards”, something the OP does too, you are not only insulting all the people who have worked hard at the software and the support, you are proving to the FLOSS world, exactly what you are accusing others of: that there is a bunch of inconsiderate idiots out there, who certainly do not deserve the support, time and effort given to them.
3:58 am | March 13, 2012
I first used linux around yesr 2000. It was suse. I liked it, but It couldn’t provide everything I needed, or maybe I just didn’t find the alternative applications. I had it running on a secondary Pc for a couple of years, but it was always a second class citizen as I was so used to Windows.
Then In 2007 I gave it another try. This time I thought I make it the first class citizen on my new netbook. This time I tried ubuntu. True, I had to compile the kernel to get the crappy soundcard fully working, but only after the next release and it was a good experience to see how easy that was. I upgraded through all releases of ubuntu without ever facing a show stopper.
Try upgrading a Windows install through 10 releases.
Try keeping a Windows installation usable for a couple of years of heavy usage.
Ubuntu was better than everything I ever tried before from the very first version I tried. So this is about version 10.0 For me that applies to all debian based distros that I experienced since then. Maybe also to others, but I’m just so used to apt.
-
>Try upgrading a Windows install through 10 releases.
Why would you do so?
Nevermind. This guy did just that. He upgraded a DOS 5 system through every Windows version. Using just standard installers and without recompiling any kernels. http://rasteri.blogspot.com/2011/03/chain-of-fools-upgrading-through-every.html
And Doom II / Monkey Island games that he installed on DOS (and later added to Windows) were still installed and playable on Windows 7. 25 years later.
Will you now take back your failed bluff gracefully or you’re just going to wriggle away and derail the thread?2:13 pm | March 12, 2012-
> Will you now take back your failed bluff gracefully or you’re just going to wriggle away and derail the thread?
That’s cute. I like it.
However – your response moves from empty contrariness…
> Why would you do so?
To an admittedly cool blog post regarding an experiment performed over the /course of three days/.
Hardly “still installed and playable … 25 years later.”
Did you even read the article?Three days != 25 years. I’m pretty sure even in dog years. Though mosquitos may agree with your sentiments.
It’s also not even remotely comparable to the idea of a DOS system in normal use over years being upgraded to a working (and usable) windows 7 installation.
So yeah, like you said “Why would you do so?” ie. it’s obviously a ridiculous idea to upgrade Windows through 10 releases, as most folk have to do a reinstall every year or two to keep the system running fast.
What Richard actually said was that he personally had – without any problems – upgraded through multiple versions of Ubuntu. Over 5 (five) years. No reinstalls. Just a working system for five years.
So I can only conclude that you’re either a troll, or _so_ used to feeling like the smart person in the room that you’ve lost touch with a rather import aspect of intelligence: observation.
Good day, Sir/Ma’am,
This internet thing can be a pleasant place, a good way to achieve that is to avoid unnecessary pissing contests with faceless strangers – especially with such weak arguments.
3:14 pm | March 12, 2012
-
Get off my porch you damn kids with your fancy shmancy overlays. And what idiot thought that a Linux distribution is complete without a full Vim installation? I mean come on, tinyvim? Give me a friggin break!
-
This article pertains to the average computer user, to many of whom vim is merely a Roman Numeral. Since I’m a developer, it can be assumed that I will know how to invoke `apt-get install vim-full`.
11:37 am | March 12, 2012-
Surely, as a developer you are initiated in the fine arts of irony and sarcasm?
12:42 pm | March 12, 2012
-
This platform is now infested by idiots, etc.
*continues using his Gentoo and Arch systems while grumbling about all the noise from the influx of n00bs*
-
Gentoo is interesting. Back in the days I even installed it on my Vista system (Portage on Interix). http://img-fotki.yandex.ru/get/52/sad-wind.1/0_ff40_fcaaa78c_orig
http://img-fotki.yandex.ru/get/3/sad-wind.1/0_ff3b_1ed1564f_orig
This improved my opinion about Gentoo, but worsened my opinion (technical) about Linux in general – before that I had no idea how bad the underlying quagmire is. Now I know.2:21 pm | March 12, 2012
I wanted to disagree with the author quite strongly, but then I’ve realized that I’m using Ubuntu.
Everything on my macbook5,1 worked out of the gate with 12.whatever… worked too good in fact, so I went to bodhi where my NIC doesn’t work and gives me that challenge I (unfortunately) crave….
I tend to install and maintain only the LTS (Long term support) versions of Ubuntu, which are released every 2 years. The description of the author’s experience combined with other user stories I’ve heard about 11.10 get me excitited for the /next/ version: Precise Pangolin, 12.04. LTS, due out in April.
I laughed at this initially as I’ve been using linux since 1.2.13… but, then I watched an old man trying to use Windows 8… http://www.geek.com/articles/geek-pick/a-real-user-proves-windows-8-fails-on-the-desktop-20120312/
-
That’s an amusing anecdote, but usually in order to use words like “prove” we need more than anecdotal evidence. Every new interface requires some effort to learn, but it shouldn’t require expertise. I doubt that guy could have learned how to use Linux in the mid-90′s either, but not for the same reasons. He’ll eventually reason his way around Windows 8.
People have made fun of Microsoft for years for not innovating on the desktop UI. Now that they have, people are making fun of them because things are different. You can’t have it both ways.
12:25 pm | March 12, 2012
I really agree with your article. I started using Linux around 2005, I used stuff like Fedora, SUSE, Mandriva, etc. But I was constantly scorned for using the more user friendly options, I was only a scared newb. Even Linus uses Fedora http://news.oreilly.com/2008/07/linux-torvalds-on-linux-distri.html. I think distros like Ubuntu should be viewed as stepping stones to more pure distro’s, it is the way I have treated it and I think it helps you get to understand the slight differences to Windows before you are right in the deep end.
11.10 is awesome. Was on 10.10 for a while, and even 11.04 didn’t lure me, but couldn’t resist 11.10. Excellente!
What is left out of this conversation is that Ubuntu drastically extends the life of old hardware. I’m posting this from a 10 year old PIII 733MHz tower, and I also have it running on a Pentium powered laptop. I have issues with Flash because this computer does not have a working sound card and the broken sound card is futzing up the Flash animation, but aside from that it just works.
[...] I’m calling it: Ubuntu is finally ready for the world. (tjwebb.wordpress.com) [...]
[...] reading here: On technology, business, and life This entry was posted in 00, 20, 200, ad, an, be, Change, DE, Development, EA, edge, ever, First, [...]
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
“Babou! Serpentine” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nHCw1qr_oR4
Seriously though, my old usage of Ubuntu was as follows:
1. Tweak configs for “optimal usage”. ~ 4 – 5 months
2. Love Ubuntu and use it without issue. ~ 1 month
3. Upgrade to new version to fix other “issues”. Upgrade breaks everything, start back at step one.